Yell or Scream at Your Kids?

Not everyone has lost their cool with their kids like me but there are many that have  yelled on occasion. I believe yelling became the go-to discipline method when child abuse was put on the books and could be “investigated” and “punished” by law. Yelling does not leave marks that you can see but the scars are still there.

To my fellow parents who yell, I would like to “show” you what yelling looks like from another’s perspective. Your face turns a lighter shade of crimson even before you utter your first yell. As soon as your child sees this they’re not sure if you are about to be sick or they are in trouble. The eyebrows meet in the middle and take on the V-shape of birds flying south for the winter and then your eyes squint as if you just chomped into a lemon. Your cheeks puff up and get hard so they can spew the words you think  will make a life-and-death difference in your child’s behavior. Your child can’t listen to what you are saying though because they are too busy watching to see what the birds are going to do. Your head is nodding as you begin to rant and gives you the appearance of a buffalo pawing the dirt to kick-off rutting season. Yeah, it isn’t pretty.

By now you are out of breath because the pacing to go with the yelling is causing partial hypoxia. You put your hands on your hips to spread your lungs to increase the supply of oxygen. Your child still hasn’t heard a word because they are too busy worrying when the first blow will fly— they wish they could think  ‘cause there’s sure to be a question-and-answer session following immediately. You deliver a summation to the condemned I’m sure Judge Judy would be proud of and toss out a few consequences for good measure. Your child is holding their breath because the end  is near; you reach over and give them a stiff hug and stomp out of the room. Right now your child takes their first, full breath and is desperately trying to figure out “what just happened.” They are completely confused by the contradiction between the fear and the possibly fake hug.

If you think that child was scared you would be right but they weren’t the only one— the windows were open at the time. The mail carrier was delivering the usual bills wrapped in advertisements as your words hit the air. The carrier double-checks the name on the mail and makes a mental note, “screamer lives here.” Your neighbor gassed up a lawnmower and overheard too, feeling pity for the child and spouse inside. The jogger passing by wonders if the authorities should be called and circles the block to get the house number.

A lot can happen on a warm day in autumn, whether you realize it or not. The mail carrier delivered to my house that day but he didn’t hear me yell— that was my husband that day years ago. Nothing can be more sobering to a yeller than realizing they have been overheard by others. In apartments or houses yellers are usually well-known by all who frequent the area, even with windows closed. (Note: My husband is not a drinker or a drunk; he is a bona fide yeller and other parents in our neighborhood would not let their children play with our children.)

From my experience as a child I can attest to the fact that yelling at children is not effective. Yelling and screaming can vent but rarely ever solves any problem. Anytime a parent approaches a child it makes more sense to have a goal in place— to understand and be understood. Calm, deliberate communication from a face that is not contorted with anger will encourage cooperation, not fear. Neither my daughter nor I remember the reason my husband yelled that day but we do remember the mail carrier— his shock and then my husband’s well-earned look of embarrassment. The moment yelling or screaming starts, the child’s focus turns to self-protection and fear, not conversation.

Copyright © 2014 Jackie Saulmon Ramirez. All Rights Reserved.

New Jersey 24-Hour Family Helpline: 1-800-THE-KIDS

Parents Anonymous® of New Jersey, Inc.
Phone: (609) 585-7666
Fax: (609) 585-7686

Join the Online Support Group
Wednesdays 9:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. EST
Thursdays 12:00 p.m. to 2:00 p.m. EST

Facebook: Parent Rap – Soup To Nuts

Parents Anonymous® Inc.
Phone: (909) 621-6184
Fax: (909) 621-0614

National Parent Helpline
1-855-4A PARENT OR 1-855-427-2736
Hours: Monday – Friday 10 a.m. to 7 p.m. PST

About Jackie Saulmon Ramirez

Jackie has volunteered for more than twenty years for children and family issues. Currently she writes for parents in the "Reminder" and "Parent Rap" Facebook page. If you are interested in receiving the "Reminder," send her a message.
This entry was posted in How-To, Parenting and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Yell or Scream at Your Kids?

  1. raisinemreal says:

    Yelling is not child abuse. What you say when you yell, can be. Sometimes a loud tone of voice is need to gain the attention of some children. Some children can be talked to and reasoned with. Other’s have to be spoken to like old deaf people.


    • Jackie Saulmon Ramirez says:

      I see what you are saying but in a Parents Anonymous group we recognize six major forms of abuse: (1) Physical Abuse, (2) Physical Neglect, (3) Verbal Abuse, (4) Emotional Abuse, (5) Emotional Neglect and (6) Sexual Abuse. Yelling, in our circles, is child abuse (Between Verbal & Emotional) and one sure way to tell is to look at the face and demeanor of the child in question; if they look happy, proud and pleased, then it is likely NOT abuse. But if the child is being yelled to and they cower from the yeller or take a protective stance, then yes, it in all likelihood IS abusive. Abusive is anything that makes a child feel fearful, ashamed, in danger, etc. I was not speaking about children who are hard of hearing or playing outside on a baseball field. Usually, I talk ‘with’ children, not ‘to’ or ‘at.’ If you are speaking of legalities, child abuse is basically anything that leaves a bruise, a mark or injures a child. As you must know, you can scream in a child’s face all day and there will never be a mark you can see, but the real damage is on the inside. Parents Anonymous holds a much higher bar for parents. For myself personally, I raise the bar even higher and the proof is in the pudding as they say. I am very pleased to have had the opportunity to clarify the Parents Anonymous definitions somewhat. Please don’t hesitate to contact me with any questions you may have. Greetings!


Share your thoughts and ideas!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s